Buzz Me In Pleasure Products Store

How to Choose the Right Anal Plug: A Buying Guide

How to Choose the Right Anal Plug: A Buying Guide

By Buzz Me In Pleasure Products Store | Published: 2026-08-30

Category: Buying Guides

Learn how to pick the perfect anal plug with our expert guide covering size, material, shape, and safety tips for beginners and pros.

Choosing the right anal plug can feel overwhelming with so many options available. Whether you're new to anal play or looking to upgrade, understanding the key factors—size, material, shape, and safety—will help you make an informed choice. This guide breaks down everything you need to know to find the perfect plug for your needs.

Anal plugs are versatile toys that can enhance solo play or partnered intimacy. They come in various sizes, materials, and designs, each offering a unique sensation. By the end of this guide, you'll know exactly what to look for and how to ensure a comfortable, enjoyable experience.

Anal Plug Size: Start Small and Work Up

Size is the most critical factor when choosing an anal plug. Beginners should start with a small plug, typically around 1 to 1.25 inches in diameter, to allow the body to adjust gradually. A plug with a tapered tip and a narrow neck is ideal because it inserts easily and stays in place comfortably.

For those with more experience, medium plugs (1.5 to 1.75 inches) offer a fuller feeling, while large plugs (2 inches and above) are for advanced users. Remember that anal tissue is delicate, so always listen to your body and never force anything. The 'Avant Suko 8" Dual Density Dildo' is an excellent option for those who want to practice with a realistic, flexible toy before moving to larger plugs.

  • Measure the diameter, not just the length, to gauge size.
  • Look for a flared base to prevent the plug from going too far.
  • Consider a plug with a suction cup for hands-free play.

Anal Plug Material: Safety and Sensation

The material of your anal plug affects both safety and sensation. Body-safe silicone is the gold standard because it's non-porous, hypoallergenic, and easy to clean. It also warms to body temperature quickly, making insertion more comfortable. Silicone plugs come in various firmness levels, from soft and squishy to firm.

Other materials include glass, which is smooth and can be temperature-played, and metal, which offers a weighty, luxurious feel. Avoid plugs made of jelly, rubber, or PVC, as these are porous and can harbor bacteria. Always choose a plug with a flared base to ensure safety. For a high-quality silicone option, consider the 'We-Vibe Vector+ in Charcoal Black', which offers both comfort and stimulation.

We-Vibe Vector+ in Charcoal Black
We-Vibe Vector+ in Charcoal Black
  • Silicone, glass, and metal are the safest materials.
  • Avoid porous materials that can't be fully sanitized.
  • Use a compatible lubricant: water-based with silicone toys.

Anal Plug Types: Find Your Perfect Fit

Anal plugs come in various shapes and styles, each designed for different experiences. Classic plugs have a tapered tip and a curved body that targets the prostate or G-spot. Vibrating plugs add an extra layer of stimulation, while inflatable plugs allow you to adjust the size during play. There are also plugs with tails or other attachments for those interested in role-play.

Consider your goals: if you're looking for prostate stimulation, a curved plug like the 'We-Vibe Vector+' is an excellent choice. For beginners, a simple, smooth plug with a gentle curve is often best. The 'Avant Kaleido Plug' (mentioned in a previous review) is a great visual and sensory option. Always ensure the plug you choose has a flared base for safety.

Avant Kaleido Plug
Avant Kaleido Plug
  • Classic plugs are great for beginners.
  • Vibrating plugs add extra pleasure but may be more intense.
  • Inflatable plugs allow for size adjustment during use.

Anal Plug Safety: Essential Tips

Safety is paramount when using anal plugs. Always use a generous amount of lubricant—preferably water-based with silicone toys—to reduce friction and prevent injury. Start with a smaller plug and gradually increase size as you become more comfortable. Never use a plug without a flared base, as it can get lost inside the body.

Clean your plug thoroughly before and after each use with warm water and mild soap or a toy cleaner. Store it in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. If you experience pain, stop immediately. Listen to your body and take breaks as needed. For beginners, consider starting with a small, body-safe plug and practicing relaxation techniques.

  • Always use lube—even if you think you don't need it.
  • Never force a plug; if it hurts, stop.
  • Check for any cracks or damage before use.

Choosing the right anal plug involves considering size, material, type, and safety. Start with a small, body-safe plug and gradually explore as you become more comfortable. Remember to use plenty of lubricant and always choose a plug with a flared base. With the right choice, anal play can be a pleasurable and rewarding experience.

Shop Related Products

Avant Pride P1- 6" Pride Dildo

Avant Pride P1- 6" Pride Dildo

$28.00 $55.99

Shop Now
Creature Cocks: Monstropus Tentacled Monster Silicone Dildo

Creature Cocks: Monstropus Tentacled Monster Silicone Dildo

$49.50 $98.99

Shop Now
Suga' Daddy 8" Silicone Dildo in Blue

Suga' Daddy 8" Silicone Dildo in Blue

$25.00 $50.00

Shop Now
Colours Dual Density 8" Dildo

Colours Dual Density 8" Dildo

$35.25 $70.50

Shop Now